Why We Need Smart Justice, Not Full Jails
We hear the very real frustrations of our local business owners whose customers feel uneasy because of the unhoused crisis on our doorsteps. We share the concerns of residents who have watched the numbers of unhoused individuals swell in our public spaces. When a new law is introduced that essentially penalizes homelessness, it can sound like an easy, necessary fix: change your circumstances, get help, move along, or go to jail.
But that proposition completely ignores the catastrophic long-term costs to the Monroe County taxpayer and the direct threat it poses to our public safety.
The reality is that jail is incredibly expensive. Right now, the Monroe County jail is severely over its legal capacity limit; so much so that the county is facing an imminent lawsuit over the facility’s incapacities. While we absolutely need to upgrade our facilities, it is crucial to remember that the current proposals will merely bring us back into legal compliance; they do not magically grant us unlimited capacity. If we are judicially forced into emergency actions or hit with penalties because our jail is overflowing, that bill will be paid directly out of your county taxes.
More importantly, the capacity crisis creates a dangerous domino effect for public safety. The core function of our jail is to ensure that dangerous criminals and violent threats are removed from our streets. When we fill our limited jail space with petty offenders whose primary “crime” is lacking a roof, it puts immense pressure on the system. It makes it far more enticing for a judge to go slack on a violent criminal or grant leniency to a repeat offender simply to make space.
Locking a person up just for sleeping on public property isn’t an easy solution; it actively degrades our ability to lock up the people who actually mean us harm.
We have to be smart about how we deploy our limited prosecutorial and law enforcement resources. Ben Arrington will not issue a blanket refusal to enforce this new law because our public spaces must remain safe and functional for everyone. However, under an Arrington administration, there will need to be clear, aggravating circumstances to justify charges. It will need to be more than simply being unhoused and sleeping on a bench.
If an individual poses a direct danger to society, such as demonstrating violence, creating clear and hazardous sanitation issues, or littering the ground with anything that could be dangerous to a child—Ben will aggressively prosecute. But the mere status of being homeless and sleeping on public property will not be enough of a reason to burden the Monroe County taxpayer with the high cost of incarceration, unless there is a clear, actionable opportunity to provide that individual with beneficial, course-changing services.
Homelessness is undeniably a complex crisis with no simple fix. Any genuine solution must begin with a systemic investigation into why Bloomington experiences such disproportionate rates of it in the first place. Only by understanding these root causes and exploring evidence-based interventions can we implement policies that actually mitigate the issue. Simply locking people up is empty political rhetoric; it offers the illusion of decisive action, but in reality, it is cynical maneuvering that burdens our community with immense hidden costs.
Leave a Reply